Rough Riders (1997)

This story has more twists and turns than a second-rate soap opera.

An old-fashioned movie made with new-fashioned finesse.

While it doesn't offer any answers, it both thrills and makes you think.

A clunky actioner with a handful of cool moments.

My main quibble with this script (and I did love the movie) was at the time I was reading my copy of Richard Harding Davis, "The Notes of a War Correspondent", his description of the battle came from the actor playing Stephen Crane's. RH Davis is worthy of a rousing action movie in his own right. Would have been a great addition to the movie.

After watching this, I decided to read about Teddy Roosevelt. Wow! The movie captures him perfectly - as his wife Edith says, "a force of nature". And then I watched the movie again, and Wow! After reading, I know that Teddy and these Rough Riders were right at the front starting the USA on a course to joining the world powers. So, this is historically important stuff. Furthermore, from what I have found out so far, the movie was factually honest. Furthermore, the movie moved right along, was entertaining, frightening, and uplifting, all at the same time. Lastly, if Teddy had not come back alive, I would have proposed to Edith - what a gorgeous gorgeous lady. This movie is now one of my favorites.

I did enjoy the movie a great deal and was able to look past some of the historical errors, (hard for a military historian). One major point is the inclusion of Fredrick Funston in the film. Funston is truly a character worth a film of his own, small town Kansa boy (Iola, Ks) makes good. While he did fight in Cuba it was prior to the Spanish American War. He was recovering from wounds in the US at the time of the war. He did raise a volunteer regiment, the 20th Kansas that later saw action in the Philippines where Funston and Privates Trembly and White of the 20th Kansas all received the Medal of Honor. Funston was later a key player in the great San Fransico earthquake and on the Mexican border prior to WW I. He was slated to command all American forces in WWI when he died suddenly in 1916 in San Antonio. The command then went to Pershing.

I think Teddy would have approved. Sometimes modern movies present the past through modern beliefs and sensibilities. In fact, more often than not directors present the past in this manner. Rough Riders is an honest movie that lets the past speak for itself with no apologies. Teddy Roosevelt and his rather diverse band of recruits believed that they were going to Cuba to save the Cuban people from an evil and exploitive Spanish colonial government. Tom Berenger completely buries himself in the character of Teddy Roosevelt without the parody that often accompanies the part. He is surrounded by a cast of excellent actors from Gary Busey as General Joe Wheeler to George Hamilton as William Randolph Hurst. Sam Elliot, Francesco Quinn, and Brad Johnson are fictional characters used to represent the range of ordinary men who followed Roosevelt. Chris Noth, Holt McCallany, and James Parke are the wealthy scions of the Wadsworth, Fish and Tiffany families. I especially liked Nick Chinlund as Frederick Remington and Adam Storke as Stephen Crane. Except for Hurst and Wheeler, these men went into the war dreaming of honor and adventure. They saw themselves as heroes going off to save the Cuban people. They were men who quoted Shakespeare's Henry V "we happy few" and believed it implicitly. The director, John Milius, and his cast of fine actors do honor to themselves and their professions by allowing these naive young men to speak for themselves and their world.