I Accuse (2003)

Yawn. Poorly Filmed Snooze Fest.

Memorable, crazy movie

Brilliant and touching

The biggest problem with this movie is it’s a little better than you think it might be, which somehow makes it worse. As in, it takes itself a bit too seriously, which makes most of the movie feel kind of dull.

I hate to sound unappreciative of any artistic endeavor, or unreceptive to stories of the weak being mistreated by the strong, but I can't help wondering how much longer they'll be grinding out scenarios that fit this template: Helpless young woman is raped (or otherwise abused) by a man (or men) of greater social worth -- here a doctor, there a famous high-school jock -- and she complains to the authorities. The authorities try to shake her off, not take her seriously. Nobody believes her. The community ostracizes her. She persists bravely and in the end manages to bring her abuser down. You can get a variation of the scenario by substituting some giant corporation for the rapist. (Cf., "Erin Brokovitch".) I understand that this is "based on a true story" and that poetic license must be granted -- but, wow. The characters could have had numbers attached to them and the narrative lifted, still throbbing, from some handbook for genre movies.In this case, the victim is a single mother in a small Canadian town. The abuser is the snooty doctor with the English accent who gives her a general anesthetic to treat some minor injuries she received in a fight with her boyfriend. While Estella Warren, as Kimberley, is all doped up, the English doc takes advantage of her to rape her.Kimberley brings a civil suit against the doctor (John Hannah), but docs have a full hand of Aesculapian authority. (Not to mention lots of money and charisma.) Who, other than a doctor, can tell the President to go to bed for a day and drink plenty of fluids? Man, that's POWER.The story then follows the usual trajectory, so ostracism is next. The whole community seems to STARE sullenly at her, wherever she goes. The close-ups we see are of faces that are old and wizened and, if they're women, they wear harlequin glasses like unto a Roz Chast cartoon. Kimberley must finally pack up and leave town, while the doctor luxuriates in his own sham aura of victimhood. In the end, the Great Physician seems to contract a case of terminal stupidity. At about the time Kimberley is read to give up, he pulls the same stunt with another young woman. The case now -- finally -- goes to court, and during his testimony the doctor explains that he tampered with evidence, obstructed justice, and committed perjury in SELF DEFENSE -- because he couldn't allow his reputation to be ruined by a young slut. I needn't reveal the verdict.Estella Warren is pretty good as the victim. She's no tiny prey, but a tall, full-bodied, and abrasive young lady. She doesn't know the meaning of the word "simper." She turns into a positive pest, and that's what the role calls for. John Hannah, as the doctor, comes across as not much more than another seasoned actor. He's not bad, but he doesn't bring anything extra to the role. The direction is competent too. There's no confusion about where we are or who's doing what, and no unnecessary displays of directorial razzle dazzle. The story is told without unmerited garnish.If I've been critical of the movie it's not because I think incidents like this don't happen, because they certainly do. Some examples have been caught on tape. It's just that we leap to the conviction that it happens SO OFTEN. My guess is that it's a pretty rare event, given everything that an established physician has to lose. So we can't claim there are thousands of sneaky doctor/rapists out there. Maybe there are, but we have no way of knowing. We need, I think, to also keep in mind that accusations are easy to make, and that they're difficult to refute because you can't prove a negative. (Prove to me that you did NOT rape this girl is a little like saying prove to me that there is no God or that there are no such things as UFOs. It can't be done.) And in judging cases like these, we need to bear in mind that it's enjoyable for some people to be a victim. (Not to be victimized, but to be thought of by others as a victim.) A certain moral weight attaches to the role. People sympathize with you and treat you with greater kindness, as with mothers in Munchhausen-by-proxy syndrome. There are two ways to get people to carry you around. One is to be powerful enough to order them to do it, and the other is to collapse. The role of victim involves a collapse in the face of irresistible social or physical forces.Given the weaknesses and the over-familiarity of the plot, though, this is a reasonably well-done movie, with Estella Warren particularly good. I don't see much point in recommending or not recommending it because, if you're fond of these kinds of films, you've seen it already in one form or another. They're kind of like the many action movies that star Schwarzenegger, Willis, Van Damme, Stallone, and the rest. If you like one, you're liable to like all.

I really like Estella Warren as an actress, but I felt that her lines were awful. I mean, her character in the movie was so obnoxious that I felt little sympathy for her and I definitely couldn't relate to her. The movie was kind of neat because it was a true story. I am from Saskatchewan and I remember hearing about the incident on the news. It was good that they did a lot of filming in Saskatchewan and I even know one of the guys that they had play a scientist, which is really neat. The movie could have been good if they had made Estella Warren's character more likable and more like a real person. The other characters were quite good and I liked how they made the whole DNA part look so scientific.

Cannot WAIT until Matt Dejong writes again! It was a story that needed to be told and he did an excellent job portraying this womens struggle for justice. I was hooked from start to finish! A job well done for sure!

Enjoyed the movie on Movie network Sunday Nov 30/03. Felt that the flashback scenes to the rape was shown too many times. Once would have been enough. the point was made. Estella Warren did a good job in her role. Reminded me of an Erin Brockovich type character but of course in a different vain.