Amreeka (2009)

So much average

It's complicated... I really like the directing, acting and writing but, there are issues with the way it's shot that I just can't deny. As much as I love the storytelling and the fantastic performance but, there are also certain scenes that didn't need to exist.

The first must-see film of the year.

Although I seem to have had higher expectations than I thought, the movie is super entertaining.

Directed and written by Cherien Dabis, the movie tells the story of a proud Palestinian Christian immigrant single mother, Muna Farah (Nisreen Faour) and her teenage son, Fadi Farah (Melkar Muallem) in small town Indiana, facing the trials and tribulations of moving to another country. Without spoiling the movie, too much, I have to say, I love how well-shot and well-written, the film is. However, I just wish, the movie would show us, more on how they were able to survive. After all, wasn't the couple that they were staying at, were behind on their mortgage and on risk, of losing their home? I really doubt, the income of working at White Castle would save this family, from being homeless, but somehow, this movie shows that magic of White Castle can solves all the economic and world problems. No really, this is how this movie plays White Castle as a savior. I never knew, how good working at White Castle was. Not only, does, working at White Castle help you, reconnect with your son, but it also helps, reconnect other family member. It's seem like the magic of White Castle can do anything. Yes, I know, most people would probably say, this movie is a bit distracting, due to how much, they talk about how awesome, it is, to work at there, and how much, the film's overused of that product placement. However, I still get what this movie message was trying to say, with its dramatic story. So the whole White Castle brand integration wasn't too off-putting, because they kinda intergrade the product placement into the film, somewhat adequate. I like the fact that Muna Farah had to work there, after finding out, that all of her money has been confiscates, during her entrance into the country. I also love the fact, that White Castle isn't pull as a one-off joke. No, she honestly grow to love, working there. It kinda make sense, once you see the movie. I also have to say, Nisreen Faour is a fine actress and she makes this movie, so entertaining, not only with her great use of humor, but her emotional range. You really do believe, that she's willing to do anything to help her child, have success in America. I can somewhat related her drive. After all, there is nothing wrong, with working at a job like that, as long, as you're working for success. So, I was rooting for her. The only thing, I can say, that was bad about her character, is that she speaks, in Broken English. Don't get me wrong, the fact that she doesn't understand, English, that well, is part, of this movie's charm. I love, the jokes about her, misunderstanding English slangs like 'Grill', or not knowing initials like 'F.O.B" (Fresh off the Boat); however, I wish the movie had subtitles for the scenes, where they were speaking English to each other. It was really hard to hear, what they were saying to each other, due to the accent. Still, I have to give them, some credit for having English subtitles, whenever, the characters were speaking Arabic. That was very useful. I also like how the movie had a great subplot about American prejudice toward Arabs, coming out of the events of 9/11 and the beginnings of the 2003's Iraq War. It was very good social commentary. However, it does kinda fell flat at parts. A good example is Fadi's sub-plot with the one-dimensional bullies. We never get to see that story-arch honestly finish. Nor was it, explain, very well. Honestly, why didn't the bullies press charges against Fadi, after getting into a fight with them and slicing their tires? You would think, they had a good case. Another issues that wasn't explain well, is how Muna's brother in law's medical practice was save. How did Nabeel (Yussuf Abu-Warda) get his patient, back? The movie is full of subplots that go nowhere, like Muma's co-worker, Matt (Brodie Sanderson) dropping out of school, and trying to get his GED. Did he get it? We will never know. Then, there is the jokes that go nowhere like Muna trying to sell, weight-pills. The movie makes a lot of jokes about her weight, but we never get to see her, work at it, at all. Despite those flaws. This movie was still heart-warming enough to overlook them. I also love, how the movie doesn't seem like an independent movie. You would think, a big studio finance this. I love how the film was able to be shot on location in Ramallah, with its limited low-budget. It helps make the film, seem realistic, because you really do see, how life in the West Bank is. It's a very tense place to live, indeed. Even the Winnipeg sites as the film's Post-9/11 suburban Chicago settlings kinda work. It's funny to hear the story, how locals mistake the White Castle set, as a real restaurant, and try to order things from there. In the end, I have to say, the filmmakers really use their limited budget, very wisely. I have to say, they must had done, a great job, to get National Geographic Society to buy all theatrical and home entertainment rights to Amreeka after its debut at Sundance. It's rarely for National Geo to pick a movie up, that isn't a documentary. So, mad props to Amreeka! Overall: While, it's not the best movie out there. It's a guilty pleasure of mine. A beautiful and heart-warming movie, worth checking out. I recommended it.

I discovered Amreeka thanks to looking at past Independent Spirit Award winners and nominees. This American-Canadian-Kuwaiti joint venture was nominated for Best Film. It's a terrifically personal look at a single woman's journey from Palestine to small town rural America. She wants a better life for her teenage son and takes the opportunity to immigrate to the United States. Her son is very excited, knowing full well what great opportunities they can have in the U.S. Unfortunately this is happening just after the United States launched Operation Iraqi Freedom to liberate Iraq from the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein. The film does not delve into the political and stays personal for the most part, dealing with the idiocy of prejudiced morons at the time, intolerant of Arabs as well as the struggles this woman and her son have. Fortunately the film also shows Americans without ignorance who accept Arab immigrants as neighbors and fellow human beings who deserve just as much respect as the next person. I was impressed from the get-go and would recommend this to all.7.9 / 10 stars--Zoooma, a Kat Pirate Screener

Lucky me, seeing Alia Shawkat twice in a row, unexpectedly, on a Saturday film night. This time she plays an American cousin to a Palestinian boy who comes to America with his mother. It starts out in Palestine (West Bank) though, and it's really interesting to get a sense of that place through a piece of film drama (other than the news or a documentary).Main character Muna Farah is played very well by Nisreen Faour, as her struggles with her new life really come across. Director Cherien Dabis said it like this, elsewhere on the net: 'had a sweetness about her [...] a kindness and a childlike sense of wonder. There was something about her that was so youthful, and yet, I could still see in her eyes the depth of sadness that her life experience had given her.' That's what I was trying to say!The story is more like a series of incidents, the main lines being Muna trying to find work and her son Fadi trying to regain his identity (though there is plenty beyond that, like how the family they stay with is coping). There is the school principal who befriends Muna, and there is the hostile schoolboy who opposes Fadi - and from there on it goes... and quite suddenly ends - leaving me to think this would have made great material for at least a miniseries.On the whole it's a very sympathetic little film - low key and low budget - truly with its heart in the right place.

I seldom comment on movies here but felt compelled to comment on this one. I say "not what you might expect" because I think a lot of people's reactions to this film are going to be heavily influenced by preconceptions about what this film is supposed to be "about." I can't blame them; if I heard that this was "a film about an Arab family's struggles after immigrating the USA after September 11th," I'd probably groan because I'd have certain expectations too. But this is not a "message" film, and if you go into it looking for messages, you're going to miss the point. Rather than political, this film is personal. You could call it simple, but it's not simplistic. Far from it; it refuses to reduce the subtlety and nuance of life to overt messages. I think that an honest, objective viewing of this movie will reveal that, the "stereotypes" and "simplifications" that some reviewers are seeing, were brought in by the reviewers themselves. This is not a perfect film, but it has a lot more depth, beauty and truth than most family dramas, and certainly more than the didactic work one might expect.