Beautiful Kate (2009)

Lack of good storyline.

Good story, Not enough for a whole film

This is a small, humorous movie in some ways, but it has a huge heart. What a nice experience.

True to its essence, the characters remain on the same line and manage to entertain the viewer, each highlighting their own distinctive qualities or touches.

I always enjoy good controversial "taboo' movies, if they are done right. And my list this week called form you guessed it, Incest! This will be only one of many films I watch this week, but my god, I hope they are all this good!!First, I am not going to spoil anything for anyone. With that out of the way, I did not know what to expect from this Australian film. But my oh my. This movie had it all. It was titillating, wrong, and yet so right at the same time. Had great characters and cinematography. The editing was spot on. Probably going to be my go to showcase how to do flash backs. Seriously well done!! It hit all the emotional cues as well. And left you depressed and hopeful at the same time.By the end I felt drained of emotion, the final minutes leading up to the credits are hard hitting. If your not to turned off by the 'incest' markings of this movie, I highly Recommend watching it. You will truly not be disappointed.

Beautiful Kate covers the emotionally wrenching comeuppance of a middle aged man venturing back to his childhood home so as to both figure out as well as address some serious issues from his life's past. He goes there with the general goal to do some serious soul searching, to tackle some items amidst a well-worn but still functioning farm-house that continues to house a father whom was always tough; the fact a mother died when he was a child; a young woman in the form of his fiancé who's travelling with him as well as a consistent sense of unease as he tries oh-so-very hard to confront personal demons which still resonate. The locale is a rather desolate and somewhat lonely patch of land based in the outback of Australia, a small enough house with quite a stretch of land around it but with very little in either direction although a whole lot in the form of history contained within.We begin with the lead, a writer in his early forties; a handsome man with the wry gift of the gab and a fairly easy-going, laid back demeanour, named Ned (Mendelsohn) who's driving across barren patches of back-o-beyond Australia in what is a long drive a character identifies as "half way across the continent" - that woman the aforementioned fiancé named Toni (Dermody). The opening echoes the twisting, turning and persistently enticing nature of the rest of the film; at once calling to mind the likes of controversial feature film/novel Lolita in its depiction of a much younger woman involved with a man she herself identifies as old, the opening constructing a seductive and sexually aggressive portrait of young Toni, whom still sports her corner-shop plastic name-tag and informs us all of her desire to be an actress. We unaware of where they're headed or where they've headed from; maybe they are running from something, the presence of Toni's name-tag perhaps suggesting a hurried exit whereas the definitive lead to proceedings is made unclear as the question as to whether Ned is savvy enough to Toni's obvious sexuality hangs over events.The film has them travel through the finer areas of the zone, specifically places that are perceived as more hostile-a territory in this, the great Australian void, as a sign informing people to 'keep out' hangs on top of a pole. On another occasion, a stray kangaroo ventures into the road and hits their car - the sight of death and blood and the result of a creature halfway to being alive and on its way to whatever's lurking after life visibly shakes Toni; Ned's reaction is far more measured, as if experience with this sort of event or material is familiar to him. Once at the family house, we realise it is still occupied by Ned's sister, Sally (Griffiths); she runs it on account of their father, Bruce (Brown), who's bed ridden and in need of frequent medical attention given his serious health condition that sees him close to death.Director Ward's screenplay brings the characters, a disparate bunch all bound by the same family name or, in Toni's case, at least some form of intensified tie to one of the family members, together on a number of occasions and has the dialogue crackle as a result. Bruce's despondent and overly pessimistic tone a gruelling overlying resonance to proceedings, as his son attempts to reconcile a series of painful and agonising memories from his youth. Sally appears the more submissive of the household; a telling, and rather more emotionally charged than you'd expect, scene between her and Ned seeing her reveal to him that she has the habit of escaping her real-life persona, or world, and into an exotic Internet chat-room Salsa bar in which everybody is beautiful and drinks are free. This desire to escape or to let oneself loose into a new body is symptomatic with lead Ned's own desire to rid the ugly memories of the past by addressing it in a fresh novel he's chosen to written, eerily ritualistic nature, at his family home. At one point, Bruce attempts to transgress the notion of Toni being the meager, flirtatious one by inferring a past characteristic unto Ned more broadly linked to that of his fondness for easy sex with women as young as Toni. Ward peppers her film with the odd notion or question which begs to be asked - perhaps it is Toni who's being fooled into whatever, maybe the characteristics and conventions which the film utilised to define her during the opening segments are closer to being used against her by this man Ned.Instilled into all of this is Toni's young, flimsy and flirtatious nature which very quickly sees her tire of her surroundings; the result of which is the toying with her husband to-be through a series of sexually charged notions, something all the more agonising when precisely what it is Ned's psychologically battling with comes to fruition. As the outsider to proceedings, Toni is our beacon upon which to experience most of these people and these surroundings for the very first time; the film slyly and highly effectively shifting gears and transferring what might be assumed to be the lead character in Toni onto that of Ned in the most natural and convincing of fashions. The film branches out and is made up of Ned's time at this house, often harking back to encompass his relationship with titular younger sister Kate (Lowe), something which is additionally given the utmost care and attention when constructed. Rachel Ward's film mutates, very slowly; even cunningly, into a rich character study as people come and go in and out of one other's lives, the whole time this catastrophic back-story lingering over proceedings, a back-story that is at once confrontative and, yes, disturbing but always morbidly fascinating as twists and turns play out in the past tense culminating in how it is our lead is why he is.

In the last year, I saw a film ("In My Father's Den") with much the same themes. In that New Zealand film, a man, a celebrated war correspondent returns to his rural home on the death of his father. There are significant unresolved frictions between father and son. The returning man had sex with a girl when a boy, had left immediately thereafter, and that drives the tension. People are unhappy (the man burns his dad's stuff) but some unknown facts about the youthful relationship (there is a brother who hid something) are revealed and the man is freed of his ghosts.The similarity with this story is so striking that it distracted me. That film managed to mix the emotions of rambling in inner hurt with the curiosity of a detective far better than this, and was thus more engaging. This is adapted for the screen and directed by an actress for her husband, who plays the dying father. So it is no wonder that the structure of the long form is sacrificed for the power of certain scenes with the old man. And it is no wonder that unduly long episodes are included to establish character, for instance, we have a quarter of the film between our returning fellow and the dopey girl he brings with him. As far as we can tell, this is to show how messed up he is with women. Meanwhile, we get nothing about his life as a writer other than he is successful and writes autobiographically inspired pieces. Wouldn't this have been important, since the implication in all such situations is that we are reading his work in seeing the story?The scenery is compelling but not folded into the story. While others may find the acting adequate or better, the only role that seemed real to me was the girl of the title. She plays a maturing Lolita temptress, and the cinematic handing of her is really quite superb. She flits in and out of the story for the first two thirds in such a way that we know she is the ghost. But then again, I just saw a similar character in "Carried Away" that was so much better integrated between the dramatic unfolding and the camera eye.So put this one down as appealing scenery, and another entry in the directors who direct their lovers database.Ted's Evaluation -- 2 of 3: Has some interesting elements.

Beautiful Kate is a film that holds captivating cinematography along with strong performances by the cast, especially Ben Mendelson. The editing made the film flow from one scene to the next, the intertwining of flashbacks with the present worked well. The remoteness of the house, surrounded by the dry, vast Flinders ranges in south Australia plays well with the dramatic storyline. when the secret is finally revealed, i was shocked it was something i had never expected, which i love. when watching this film you become engaged in the characters and their pain, it really makes you react, however it can make you uncomfortable at times,it all adds to the experience.The style is very rough and confronting which to me makes it interesting to watch. overall Beautiful Kate is another great Australian film, which i strongly recommend to others.