The Shadow on the Window (1957)

People are voting emotionally.

Just perfect...

One of the worst ways to make a cult movie is to set out to make a cult movie.

Actress is magnificent and exudes a hypnotic screen presence in this affecting drama.

Several years before this came out, Columbia had made an above average thriller called "The Night Holds Terror", a definite copy-cat of "The Desperate Hours" where a traveling businessman ends up giving a lift to a group of thugs who hold his family hostage, and here, it happens again, albeit with several dramatic changes. It's "All in the Family" for Philip Carey (who once played Archie Bunker's gay football player friend in a first season episode) and Betty Garrett (Archie's nemesis, Irene) who are separated due to her desire to go back to work. The opening scene has their son (Jerry Mathers, as different as Beaver as you can get!) spying his mother being thrown to the ground during a struggle with a group of thugs and the old man who has hired her for the day being killed. He runs off in a daze, is picked up by some truckers, and ends up in police custody where ironically his father is called in after another officer recognizes him. Garrett's whereabouts are a mystery to everybody who knows her, and it is only through some clever calculating that her location is discovered, hopefully in the nick of time.While this is a very enjoyable thriller, it seems like there is a lot of padding added to make this even get to its 72 minute running time, pretty short for a movie of the late 50's. That indicates that it was a second feature, a breed slowly dying out at this time, but there is enough action to keep it moving. The problem is the variety of existential characters added, from the drunken warehouse foreman whom the truckers dumped Mathers on and his awaiting wife (not to mention his mistress), and the dead old man's niece and her husband who obviously only keep in touch with him so they'll end up in his will. What is very interesting is how Garrett manages to manipulate the three men holding her hostage, gaining the sympathy of one of the men who knows that his partner (John Drew Barrymore, billed simply as John Barrymore Jr.) is a violent psycho. Of course, when you get the criminals arguing with each other, it is pretty obvious that they will eventually turn on each other. Carey ends up in a chase with the third thug, leading to an emotional scene with that gangster's mother and a chase on the apartment rooftop that leads to more clues but also leads to a violent finale.This was a far different role that Broadway musical legend Betty Garrett had ever played in, having been mostly in a handful of musical films like "On the Town", "Take Me Out to the Ballgame", and most recently, "My Sister Eileen". She only has one scene with husband and son Carey and Mathers, but obviously had worked with them for family photos which Carey finds still up when he visits his former home to find some clues. "One Life to Live" fans will be delighted to see the future Asa Buchannan in this major part, a reminder that he was once one of the busiest action/western stars in films, not just a future soap patriarch. Mathers is very touching (and convincing) as the mostly quiet kid, scared into silence by the violence he's witnessed. Yet, there's no confusion that this is none other than the future Beaver Cleaver from his very first shot, wearing cowboy gear, and clicking a toy gun. This is definitely worth a look for how 1950's thrillers of all types could engross you even though they could have easily been made for the then popular genre of Anthology shows which were all over the T.V. airwaves of the 1950's and 60's.

Better than expected thriller about a home invasion robbery gone wrong. Jerry Mathers plays a young boy who witnesses a murder at a home where his mother (Betty Garrett)is working. In shock, the boy wanders off before being picked up by a passing truck. He is dropped off with the police where it so happens the boy's father, Phil Carey, is a detective. Unable to get the boy to talk, the police begin a city-wide dragnet hoping to grab up someone who might know the location of Garrett. John Barrymore Jr., Corey Allen and Gerald Sarrcini are the not so bright hoods holding Garrett. Having murdered Garrett's boss during the robbery they must decide whether to kill her as well. Several gun battles and a couple of more bodies are piled up before Carey saves the day with a just in time rescue. OK time-waster.

Curiosity value concerning the appearance and acting skill of Barrymore (John's son and Drew's dad) will likely draw several viewers to this minor crime drama, a sort of "Despondent Hours". Garrett, separated from her policeman hubby (Carey), takes a job steno-graphing for an elderly man with her young son in tow. When three toughs break in to rob the man, but accidentally kill him, Garrett's son (Mathers) slips into a degree of catatonia and wanders off along the highway. Eventually, Carey, Garrett's husband, is reunited with the mute boy and it's a race against time to find Garrett before the punks have their way with her or kill her. The hoods are played by Barrymore, Allen and Sarracini. Carey reacts to his estranged wife's disappearance with all the concern and terror that he might have if, say, his shirt were ironed too long and got a triangle-shaped stain on the pocket. Though impossibly big and reasonably handsome, he lets his stoicism as a police officer take too much precedence over any human emotion. Garrett (pushing forty, but playing 27 and referred to as "girl"!) does a decent enough acting job, but, in keeping with the times of the film, behaves pretty foolishly more often than not. She does try to come up with a few futile attempts at escape, though. Mathers is in over his head in his tiny part and would do much better later that year in "Leave it to Beaver" where murder wasn't a part of the storyline. Barrymore is very animated and quite handsome. He leans toward the hammy aspects of acting that so many James Dean imitators were going for at the time, but his portrayal is surprisingly polished (and this isn't exactly a strong screenplay he's dealing with!) Allen (who worked with James Dean in "Rebel Without a Cause") gives the most believable and natural performance of the hoods and is very attractive in a boy-next-door way. In fact, these two "vicious criminals" do their dirty work in pullover knit sweaters and cardigans!!! They are quite a contrast to Marlon Brando in "The Wild One". The third boy is played by hulking Sarracini and he is more authentic-looking (ironically, this actor died the year this film was made from the results of a fight!!) There are so many hilariously bad bit players in the film whose dialogue and performances are side-splitting. One lady mutters that her husband doesn't like anything as much as corned beef while he is shown romancing a blonde tart in a bar. Still, the direction is surprisingly adept and there is a memorable rooftop shootout that continues into the subway which is quite impressive. A little more enthusiasm/fret from Carey might have kicked it up a notch.

Starring Jerry Mathers as the shell-shocked child who witnesses an assault on his mother, Shadow On the Window is a decent 'B' film with a solid cast and a decent script. Jerry's dad, a police officer, is played stoically by Phil Carey and mom is Betty Garrett, decent as a woman under constant threat from three stereotypical teen bad boys. One of the boys is played by Corey Allen, who revisited the role in the similarly themed Key Witness (1960), and the others are John Drew Barrymore--apparently channeling the spirit of an evil Dobie Gillis--and lovable lunk Gerald Sarracini. Beach Party director William Asher displayed his serious side here, and cinematographer Kit Carson got some nice set-ups during the climactic chase scene across roof tops and through subway tunnels. I'd love to know where this was filmed--perhaps somewhere in the Imperial Valley of California?