Kyun...! Ho Gaya Na (2004)

I love this movie so much

Sorry, this movie sucks

If the ambition is to provide two hours of instantly forgettable, popcorn-munching escapism, it succeeds.

The film makes a home in your brain and the only cure is to see it again.

The most annoying part of the movie .. poor story.. poor poor acting by Aish and Vivek... I never liked Viveks acting after Company ... His acting is completely mediocre... and lots and lots of stpidity .. even Big B's appearance could not lift this up... a complete waste of time !!! I don't know why Aishwarya is spoiling her career doing movies like these ... and that jackass Vivek will never learn how to act unless he gets rid of his stupid jackass attitude... This movie lacks everything from a good storyline to proper screenplay ... God knows when will Indian directors learn to put in everything in the right place I would not recommend this crap to anyone... except if you want to waste your time and blame the movie in the end

I found this movie charming. If you want to relax, to laugh and to live a love story...that's the movie. It's not a monument of smartness or intrigues...But the simplicity (at times), reality (other times), and the unexpected retorts ...are magnificent. Your heart is melting, your eyes are shining, and your face is smiling...I was conquered... The love story is much more "intelligent"...not the habitual one (he falls in love, she does it too but then come the problems)...this one is much more interesting ...there are fights and foolish things, contradictions and unexpected reactions,and even when there is sadness...there is a smile in it...Take your time and see it, especially if you are a romantic and funny person...but take your girlfriend/ boyfriend with you. You'll love it.

An overall fun story to watch, but the character played by Vivek should have portrayed some "heaviness" in himself, not just the one that Vivek played. But I guess this film was targeted for the young teenagers, which is why most adults don't appreciate it as much as the teenagers. Of course there is Big B, who plays one of the major characters, with lots of jokes and fun, but I guess the story lacks pretty much behind in scripts...some serious conversations should have taken place between the leading characters? Sunil Shetty and Diya Mirza are nice surprises though, and come to think about it, Diya Mirza herself would have suited more for the role of "Diya" than Aishwarya. Besides, I did not like the way Vivek was fooled because the whole fooling process doesn't explain why Aishwarya had to show strong affinity towards Sunil in front of Vivek himself. However, the songs merit credits - keep up!

i really don't understand where all the lack of enthusiasm is coming from! i absolutely loved the movie! i must say that i think the 1st part is better than the 2nd, but nevertheless it was a very funny movie with lots to offer. it was neither boring nor cliché! and i must say that the major asset to this movie were the great songs. since i am a great fan of bollywood i have seen many but these are very up to date and in my opinion very beneficial to the movie! I think that vivek oberoi was great, he is not only hansom but can dance amazingly, fabulous sense of rhythm. aishwarya beautiful as she is was in my opinion slightly irritating. but overall both main actors did a great job. also the great Amitabh Bachchan who in every movie proves his skill. in my opinion this movie deserves two thumbs up. enjoy !!