Caught in a Cabaret (1914)

I wanted to but couldn't!

At first rather annoying in its heavy emphasis on reenactments, this movie ultimately proves fascinating, simply because the complicated, highly dramatic tale it tells still almost defies belief.

This is a gorgeous movie made by a gorgeous spirit.

The film never slows down or bores, plunging from one harrowing sequence to the next.

This is another two reel comedy manufactured in Mack Sennett's comical factory out in Californy state. It caused so much laughter you couldn't hear what the actors was talkin'. Charles Chaplin was the leading fun maker. Mabel Normand, with several of the actors finished the show artistically. Sennett must have been behind the camera. Continuous laughter greeted the offering. - The Moving Picture World, May 9, 1914

Watching Charlie Chaplin's Keystone comedies is like watching the earliest appearances of classic cartoon characters such as Mickey Mouse or Bugs Bunny; that is, our hero is certainly familiar yet not quite himself, and is crude in both appearance and behavior, sometimes to a startling degree. It's fascinating to see these early works, but they can be a little disquieting, too. In some Keystones Chaplin is an outright villain, shockingly mean-spirited and dastardly. In others, however, he is comparatively benign, as in Caught in a Cabaret, an early short I enjoy, which is of special interest for several reasons.When this film was made Chaplin was not yet his own director. Caught in a Cabaret was directed by his co-star, Mabel Normand, who had clashed with the temperamental Englishman on their previous collaboration, Mabel at the Wheel. Studio boss Mack Sennett almost fired Chaplin on that occasion, but by the time this follow up was made, it appears that all was forgiven. (Chaplin's burgeoning popularity with the public was surely a big factor in saving his career at Keystone.) Both stars contributed to this film's scenario, and here is where we find a number of elements Chaplin would develop and refine later on. The basic premise is certainly familiar: Charlie is a lowly waiter who pretends to be a dignitary, and finagles an invitation to a party where he mingles with the upper crust, which makes this short a blue-print for a number of memorable comedies yet to come, including The Count, The Rink, and The Idle Class, among others. Naturally, the prototype isn't as polished as the later works, but hey, you have to start somewhere. As a bonus, Caught in a Cabaret offers a rogue's gallery of Keystone players in support: Edgar Kennedy, Chester Conklin, Minta Durfee, Mack Swain, etc., all emoting at full throttle, not to mention the lovely Mabel as leading lady, so there's plenty to enjoy as this two-reel extravaganza unfolds.The cabaret where Charlie works is a real dive, seamy and scuzzy. During the cabaret scenes director Normand crowds the frame with so much rowdy activity—people carousing, raising hell, caterwauling, whatever—that the joint looks like Bedlam. When Charlie steps outside to walk his dog, we're treated to grimy location shots taken in L.A.'s old Chinatown district, a ghetto that would be demolished in the '30s. By way of contrast, Mabel plays a "Society Bud" of noble lineage who lives in a mansion, and it's clear that she and her foppish boyfriend (Harry McCoy) travel in more rarefied circles. The denizens of these very different worlds meet up in a park, where Charlie defends Mabel from a thief while her boyfriend cowers. But it's not enough for Charlie to be a hero; he must claim to be an important figure to impress this young lady, though once he's invited to her party he forgets himself and promptly gets hammered. Harry the fop gets his revenge by inviting his society pals to go slumming at the very cabaret where Mabel's new love interest works, thus revealing his true status. It all ends in a classic Keystone mêlée, although oddly it's cabaret boss Edgar Kennedy who inexplicably freaks out and shoots up the place.There are a number of moments to savor: Mabel and Charlie sharing an intimate moment during the party, and singing along with the musicians; Minta Durfee's saucy dance in the cabaret; tough guy Mack Swain picking his teeth with a pistol; and finally, Mabel's horrified reaction at the end, when she learns that Charlie isn't really a V.I.P. (You can read her lips: "A WAITER? Oh my God!") The only thing that troubles me about this amusing short is the fate of Charlie's lively little dog. He makes quite an impression during his brief sequence before the cameras, but when Charlie returns to the cabaret from the park, the dog is no longer with him. Where did he go? And didn't anyone notice?

Caught In A Cabaret explores a couple of Chaplin's ongoing themes in his films while still incorporating many of the familiar elements the public had come to expect from him. Mabel Normand is listed as the writer/director of this film, but Chaplin is known to have contributed his direction as well. Chaplin is a waiter in a drinking establishment who later poses as someone of importance while saving a lady from a masher, as it was called in those days. Chaplin attends a high-hat party and then later on the lady and her friends decide to go slumming in Charlie's establishment. Chaplin has to quickly revert to a slummer himself so as not to give things away. Instead of choosing to end the film by making a point about classicism, Chaplin simply ends it with a pie fight. He stuck to the familiar and was not ready to become a more "serious" comedian yet. ** of 4 stars.

"Caught In A Cabaret" marks one of the first teamings of Mabel Normand and Charlie Chaplin, two of the titans of film comedy! Their playing is far subtler and wittier than that of their contemporaries at Keystone or at the other comedy studios.Their chemistry is great together. Now that it is out that Mabel Normand directed several of her own and others' comedies at Keystone, what a treat to have been on the set and story conferences where she and Chaplin worked. "Caught in A Cabaret" is also noteworthy for the teaming of Chaplin and Fatty Arbuckle. Comedy heaven! As if that weren't enough, Arbuckle's then-wife, Minta Durfee (a formidable light comedienne in her own right) rounds out the cast. Her scenes with Arbuckle are light and playful while her chemistry with Mabel Normand would've warranted an all-female comedy team.While the film's pictorial quality has obviously aged, it shows a Victorian-era Los Angeles.A fun, enjoyable two-reeler with a cast unmatched since "Libeled Lady" (1936)!