When Johnny Comes Marching Home (1942)

Sadly Over-hyped

Absolutely the worst movie.

Great story, amazing characters, superb action, enthralling cinematography. Yes, this is something I am glad I spent money on.

By the time the dramatic fireworks start popping off, each one feels earned.

After being a little disappointed in seeing Donald O'Connor not having much of a dancing showcase in either Private Buckaroo or Get Hep to Love, it's finally gratifying seeing him really cutting the rug here with Peggy Ryan doing so many turns with him during those sequences. Operatic singer Gloria Jean also joins in with them in her more demure way. Allan Jones and Jane Frazee also sing a couple of wonderful love duets here. Then there's the luminous and exciting charm of the Phil Spitalny and his "Hour of Charm" All-Girl Orchestra with Evelyn and her Magic Violin. Also, The Four Step Brothers do tap dance up a storm with their athletic spins and somersaults. Never mind the story which relates to the World War II period, just enjoy the variety of musical performances in When Johnny Comes Marching Home. P.S. The print I saw had the final number in washed out tones with the volume a little lower though you could still hear a little clearly even then.

Allan Jones is a war hero who comes home on sabbatical not in uniform, and the people surrounding him fear the worst in this delightfully simple musical about the challenges of war at home. He's actually on a secret assignment, and they believe he's AWOL. His younger brother (Donald O'Connor) looks up to him like a younger brother should, yet Jones is not allowed to reveal the truth about why he's home for such a long sabbatical as 10 days. While home, Jones finds a bit of romantic intrigue with sophisticated Jane Frazee who anxiously wants her younger sister (Gloria Jean) to pursue a career as a singer of classical music rather than the jazzy stuff she performs with O'Connor and their pal (Peggy Ryan, who gets to utter one of the funniest lines I've ever heard in a movie, "Let's have fun while we're still young and still have sense!"). This leads to a variety of types of music and some dance numbers that outshine some of the bigger musicals at larger Hollywood studios of the time.There's a sensational acrobatic number with the Four Step Brothers, a black dancing troop that rival the Nicholas Brothers (over at 20th) and Berry Brothers (at MGM). The musical numbers come fast and furious, and leave enough room for the plot so the film never slows down like some virtually plot less musicals of the same era did. While the songs are obscure in today's catalog of the great American songbook, they are certainly worth re-discovering. Unlike some larger budget propaganda musicals of the time, the patriotism here never seems forced, making the title appropriate as it reminds us now (as it attempted then) that freedom is something worth fighting for, and as long as men are willing to fight for it, the world will continue to rise above tyranny.

This B&W '42 Universal film, now viewable at You Tube, has about everything a wartime audience might wish for in a musical comedy: a well-balanced cast that provide a blend of classical ballads, hep cat teenage dancing and singing, a strong patriotic wartime presence, the impressive gymnastic dancing of the Four Step Brothers, and the novelty of an all girl orchestra and singing group.War hero Johnny Kovacs(Allan Jones) steps off a troop ship for 30 days leave in his home town(apparently NYC), but is greeted with endless speaking engagements and a bothersome infatuated young woman(Maria Shelton, as Diana Wellman). Thus, he gets permission from his commander to 'hide' from further unwanted attention by assuming his pre-war identity as singer Johnny O'Rourke. Hence, he decides to ask some previous musical friends (Flanagans) to let him room at their house for the remainder of his leave. Trouble is they only know him as Jimmy O'Rourke, and they overhear him talking on the phone about the problem that the media people haven't been informed about his little ruse, and are looking for him as a missing soldier. The Flanagans and friends thus assume Jimmy has gone AWOL, and singer Joyce(Jane Frazee), whom Jimmy likes, starts avoiding him. When detectives arrive at the Flanagan's, looking for Jimmy,teens Don O'Connor and Gloria Jean, along with Joyce, pretend they don't know where he is. But teen Peggy Ryan, who doesn't know about the assumed problem, tries to spill the beans. Their alternative ad hoc descriptions of what Jimmy looks like, summed up by Peggy's wildly contradictory statement is hilarious. When Jimmy decides to sing at a local club, the gang are afraid he will be court- martialled and executed, and try to stop him. They're too late, but finally learn that Jimmy O'Rourke is also Jimmy Kovacs, and has done nothing wrong. Everyone gets to sing or dance in the final stage show, along with some films of various servicemen and war equipment in a flag-waving grand finale.We have half a dozen featured singers, in addition to the comical exuberant dancing of Don O'Connor and Peggy Ryan, and the gymnastic and superfast tap dancing of the African American 'Four Step Brothers'. The latter had been around for nearly 2 decades, and look like they could have easily challenged Gene Kelly or an older Don O'Connor with their athletic tap dancing. They very much remind me of the Nicholas Brothers(only 2): featured dancers in a number of mostly Fox musicals of this era. They have 2 performances: one in typical Fred Astaire top hat,tux, and cane guise( more entertaining than typical Fred?). Later, in military uniform, they mock-drill to the march "American Patrol", which had been resurrected as a pop song that year by the Glenn Miller Orchestra.Don, Gloria Jean, and Peggy formed the core teen friendship group, with Don favoring Gloria as a girlfriend(as usual), but not wanting to hurt Peggy, his favorite dance partner. They perform two notable song and dance routines:"One of Us Has Gotta Go", near the beginning, and the more spectacular "Say It with Dancing", as part of the grand finale show(Both this site and the Wikipedia site wrongly ascribe this performance to stars Allan Jones and Jane Frazee). Gloria had a solo "Green Eyes" sing, sang part of the romantic ballad standard "You and the Night and the Music", along with Allan and Jane, and had a duet with Allan to "Romance". Of course, this was only one of a number of Universal films made in '42-'43 that featured at least 2 and often 3 of these charismatic teen performers.Don and Peggy would continue to form a team in several more films released in '44 and '45, before Don was drafted into military service. Meanwhile Gloria Jean was teamed with other actors in her future, mostly forgettable, Universal films, which ended in '45, as did Peggy's.First-billed Allan Jones was an established film singing star and former coal miner, who played Jimmy Kovacs/O'Rourke, and got the most singing roles, with his fine operatic voice. Besides his afore-mentioned shared songs, he had a duet with Jane Frazee to "This is it, This is Love", and began the extended group sing of the flag-waving "The Yanks are Coming Again". This song is based on the WWI Cohen "Over There" lyrics. Allan had costarred in the '36 film version ofKerns' "Showboat", and with Jeanette MacDonald, in "Firefly", and would continue his music career long after his Hollywood years ran out....Jane Frazee, as Gloria's older sister and Allan's girlfriend, also a trained singer, didn't get any solos, except as part of the duet sings, and a bit part in the group sing "This is Worth Fighting For"Part of the charm of this film is that it is one of only two feature films that included Phil Spitalny and his 'All Girl Orchestra', which had performed on radio, stage and in film shorts since '34. I must say they sounded great, including the solo trumpeter, who could have challenged Harry James, and the solo violinist. The orchestra members also presumably functioned as the all girl singing group for several songs.

"When Johnny Comes Marching Home, was one of several musicals made by Universal during the WW2 years. This one was different from most made during this era in that it was aimed not only at teenagers, but at the adults as well.This movie was shot in 1942, at a time in which the USA was just starting to get heavily involved in WW2. The plot is simple: A war hero is on a 30 day leave and wants to spend his furlough in peace and anonymity. He assumes a different name and settles in. In the process, the people he's around mistakenly think he's a deserter and scheme to convince him to turn himself in. Dramatic irony sets in, the usual complications ensue, and eventually everything gets straightened out. The movie gets zealously patriotic at times, and some of the situations in the movie are dated to the war years and won't be fully understood by those not familiar with how times were then.Universal didn't really splurge on acting talent in this film. Well-known Allan Jones and Jane Frazee highlighted the marquee, with studio contract-kids Gloria Jean, Donald O'Connor, and Peggy Ryan doing their part. The rest of the cast were pretty much stock. What Universal didn't scrimp on was entertainment; the movie is packed with it from beginning to end. Jones, Frazee and Jean all sing several songs. Popular Phil Spitalny appears with his "all girl orchestra". O'Connor and Ryan are their usual zany selves, and of course they perform a couple of their energetic dance routines (with Jean joining them briefly in each), and they even sing. Violinist Evelyn Silverstone (billed as "Evelyn and her Magic Violin"), who later gained fame with Lawrence Welk, performs a couple of virtuoso numbers. Other song and dance routines are worked in by others. As was the case in many of these musicals, Universal basically built the story around the entertainment.I haven't seen this movie on TV in recent years, but as is the case for every movie that Gloria Jean appeared in, you can buy a copy from Gloria herself on her website. IMDb policy forbids the listing of URLs, but you can find her website by using a search engine and her full name of "Gloria Jean Schoonover." If you're a fan of the old "B" musicals, you'll want to see this one.