Black Patch (1957)

Best movie of this year hands down!

Excellent adaptation.

A great movie, one of the best of this year. There was a bit of confusion at one point in the plot, but nothing serious.

This movie tries so hard to be funny, yet it falls flat every time. Just another example of recycled ideas repackaged with women in an attempt to appeal to a certain audience.

An offbeat Western. Scripted by Gordon, who also takes the role of the friend turned bankrobber that marshal Montgomery is accused of murdering for the Money, Black Patch is directed with verve by Miner, a protégé of Robert Aldrich. Pittman contributes a distinctly modern interpretation of his role as the distraught teenager who faces up to Montgomery at the climax.Phil Hardy

"Ghost Town" director Allen H. Minor's "Black Patch" doesn't qualify your typical 1950s western. This George Montgomery oater unfolds like most, but it concludes with an unusual ending. Comparably, the ending of "Black Patch" anticipated the ending of the 1970s' Burt Lancaster sagebrusher "Valdez is Coming" where everything was left hanging as everybody prepared to shoot it out. Of course, the outcome was clearly predictable, and this was why the scene wasn't played out in its entirety. Similarly, "Black Patch" withdraws before the heroic Montgomery stomps off to deliver the comeuppance to the perfidious villains. Interestingly enough, Sebastian Cabot plays chief villain Frenchy De'vere, with help from his right hand man House Peters, Jr. After convicted bank robber Leo V. Gordon pulled a stretch in San Quentin, he became a scenarist as well as one of the most formidable heavies in Hollywood. Gordon was probably the most menacing villains in 1950s. He penned the above-average script here that casts the rugged Montgomery as a town lawman with one eye, justifying the title "Black Patch." Most of "Black Patch" occurs in the town with an occasional scene in the wilderness. Marshal Clay 'Patch' Morgan (George Montgomery of "Masterson of Kansas") has no patience for drifters. Indeed, he runs them out of Santa Rita in short order. One day, however, an old friend, Hank Danner (Leo V. Gordon of "Riot in Cell Block 13"), rides into town to rendezvous with his new wife, Helen Danner (Diane Brewster), and introduce her to Patch. Things start to stink. Apparently, Patch and Helen were once a romantic item. You have to wonder what kind of a friend Hank is since he all but rubs Patch's nose in the fact that he has married the woman that once loved Patch. Not long afterward, Patch learns that Hank may have been a bank robber. Two lawmen ride into Santa Rita, and they accuse Hank of robbing a bank. Sheriff Ben Maxton (Ted Jacques of "Powder River Rustlers") and Deputy Pete Walker (Strother Martin of "Cool Hand Luke") inform Clay that a lone gunman absconded with over $40-thousand from the Clinton Bank the day before yesterday. Since the robbery, Maxton has organized a half a dozen posses covering every road running for fifty miles out of town. They last saw the robber traveling north. "This fella's a real slick one," Sheriff Maxton explains. "Now, he might have doubled back and figured we might have scattered north." As it turns out, Deputy Walker witnessed the robbery, and he gives a description that fits Hank Danner. "Well, he's a big fella, dressed rough, in black, and he came in as nice as you please. But before we could blink, he had the drop on us." Patch and the Clinton lawmen head for the hotel, but Hank surprises them. "Better put it down, Hank," Patch warns him. "You'll never make it." Hank dismisses any chance of escape and surrenders his six-gun to Patch. Reluctantly, Patch locks Hank in his upstairs jail, but Hank has a six-gun smuggled into his cell by a drunken gunman, Holman (House Peters, Jr. of "Rio Conchos"), who serves as the right hand to slimy, bar owner Frenchy De'vere (Sebastian Cabot) who has no love lost for Patch. They give him the gun in exchange for $20-thousand, but Frenchy soaks the bullets in champagne so they won't discharge. Holman rides out to where we first saw Hank and digs up the loot. Later, Hank forces Patch to open his cell and a rough and tumble fistfight ensues. Hank scrambles out of the jail, but the treacherous Holman shoots him twice in the back. When he comes barreling out of his office, Patch blasts away twice at the fleeing figure of Holman as the drunkard lurches into the ally. Everybody believes that Patch shot Hank in the back, and Karl (Tom Pittman) who cleans Patch's rifles when he isn't killing flies at the hotel turns against him. Helen wants nothing to do with Patch, and she gives Hank's gun and gunbelt to Karl. The change that Karl goes through is pretty conspicuous. He is transformed into an arrogant gunslinger, and he shoots rather well considering that he hasn't had Hank's Colt revolver for long. He turns against Patch, but ultimately they become friends again after Patch refuses to shoot it out with him.The casting of Leo V. Gordon as an initially good citizen is unusual. Look for Dan Blocker as a blacksmith and Robert Mitchum's brother John as a gambler. "Black Patch" isn't a landmark western, but it offbeat enough to watch.

Black Patch is directed by Allen H. Miner and written by Leo Gordon. It stars George Montgomery, Diane Brewster, Tom Pittman, Leo Gordon, Strother Martin and Sebastian CabotA veteran of the Civil War, Clay Morgan (Montgomery), minus an eye, decided not to return to his home town and started afresh in Santa Rita, New Mexico. Working as the town marshal, and keeping very good order, his equilibrium is upset when an old friend and his wife arrive in town. When news comes about a bank robbery in a nearby town, it signals the start of events that will see Clay forced into dark corners…Sometimes a Western fan will stumble upon a movie and wonder why it isn't better known. Black Patch is one such Oater, which in the grand scheme of things is criminal. More so when you consider the cast list, the cinematographer and the musical scorer (it was Goldsmith's first movie score and his fans will spot the early strains of some future work).Beautifully photographed through a black and white film noir filter, Black Patch is big on mood. Be it oppressive as Miner works wonders within the confines of the Monogram Ranch locale, or psychologically pungent as the principal players battle their hang-ups and heartaches, there is not a single frame in the picture that isn't laced with adult Western textures.The characters are presented with emotional depth, not as some Western shoot-out roll call of cannon fodder. The romantic angle is nicely etched, never cloying the story but adding to the bubbling enigma of the human condition. Gordon writes himself a good part, but he isn't interested in writing a Yee-Haw Good Guys Vs Bad Guys genre piece, there's a lot of interesting characters here who are all damaged or hurting in one way or another.Having Montgomery in the lead helps, he was always a real good brooder, and he does it with considerable pathos here, and with Colman (Walk a Crooked Mile) and Miner (The Ride Back) favouring film noir techniques, Monty is often framed in classic noirish style. Brewster (The Young Philladelphians) blends both sultry with sincere regret, Cabot (Terror in a Texas Town) has a good old time of it as the town weasel, while young Pittman (The Proud Rebel) gives his young character the requisite pangs of confusion as he tries to make sense of everything around him.This is very much one for the psychological adult Western crowd, not one for those who prefer stunts and fights every ten minutes. It has a few faltering moments, such as a turn of events involving the Pittman and Brewster characters, but this particular black patch is actually gold for the like minded adult Western fan. 8/10

Black Patch is a routine western notable for being the first film scored by Jerry Goldsmith, a composer who would go on to some very great things indeed: Planet Of The Apes, Papillon, Chinatown, The Omen, Alien, Total Recall, Basic Instinct, L.A. Confidential and hundreds more. Naturally, Black Patch doesn't sound anything like those works, but Goldsmith's characteristic voice is unmistakable, if not yet fully formed.Despite only being in his late twenties, Goldsmith wrote music that indicated a fledgling dramatic sensitivity and intelligence that would blossom into the hallmarks of his career. So, for the composer at least, it was a good start musically even if the film itself was modest.